Monday, September 28, 2009

Old Fashioned Buttermilk Pie

Tuesdays at the Table

Tasty Tuesday
Image and video hosting by TinyPic

This a recipe from The Pantry restaurant in McKinney, Texas. If any of you have been to The Pantry you know what I'm talkin' 'bout! Everything in there is absolutely wonderful!
The Recipe:3 eggs
1 1/2 cups sugar
2 tablespoons flour
dash of salt
1 cup buttermilk
1/2 cup margarine melted, and cooled to room temp
1 teas vanilla
1 deep dish pie shell

Mix first 7 ingredients together. Beat for 3 minutes on med speed (very important). Pou into pie shell. Bake at 400 degrees for 10 minutes. Lower heat to 350. Bake additional 35 minutes until center is set.
It is important that melted margarine is cool before adding eggs, or they will not blend properly.
Image and video hosting by TinyPic
Thanks to Cole at All the Small Stuff for hosting Tuesdays at the Table. Thanks to Jen at Balancing Beauty and Bedlam for hosting Tasty Tuesday.


Kara said...

I LOVE buttermilk pie! Thanks for sharing.

SnoWhite said...

Never heard of buttermilk pie -- had to come see what it was. Looks mighty tasty!

Jodi said...

Never heard of this before, sounds good.

Stacey said...

One of our very favorites! In our family, my dad makes them. His recipe makes two pies at a time and believe me...we eat it all! I saw that SnoWhite had never heard of them. I think it's very southern or Texan, don't you?

shopannies said...

my mother used to make delicious chess pies thanks for the recipe

heartnsoulcooking said...

My mom loves chess pie. THANKS!!! for the recipe. Geri

Cole said...

I have never heard of buttermilk pie - but your photo makes it look GREAT!

Tracy said...

Yummy! I'll have to write this one down for Dad loves buttermilk pie!
Hope you are well!

AndreaLeigh said...

i've never tried this but it looks delicious! thanks for sharing.

Nancy said...

Lisa, I love buttermilk pie!! YUM YUM!! Yours looks delish! Nancy

Tee said...

Does buttermilk pie actually taste like buttermilk (hope not!), or just sweet and vanilla-ish? I once worked for a man whose wife made something called sawdust pie - maybe the same? It was delicious!! Is there a schedule for the book club? I've picked up the Guernsey book many times but could never get excited about it. But if you say it's good, I'm gonna read it. I'll grab a button.

Cathy said... read my mind!!! I was going to make this pie the other day and I could not find my I can use yours!!! My kids get to where they are just craving buttermilk pie...I try not to make it too often...but we just love it...yummy!!!

Thank you!!!

Melissa Miller said...

Oh goodness Lisa I just love Buttermilk pie.
I can't look at it since it will just make me hungry. I'll eat it again just not right now. LOL! Thanks for your kind encouragement. I feel great!

~Happy Fall! ~Melissa :)

PS I didn't know Mums were for November B-days? My hubby's is on the 18th. Neat!

Libby Murphy said...

Anyone who doesn't like Buttermilk Pie has never had a bite I bet. Some people may not like to drink buttermilk, but this is a whole different story.
Happy Twirls

Mrs. G said...

Yum, love buttermilk pie. A little shop near where I used to live served it. My other mother also makes a version of it that she calls Cream Pie. When she makes it we all come a runnin.

It is good to be back, thanks for coming by.


Susie Q said...

Oh this pie looks sooo good! I haven't had it in a while. Hmmm...why not this week? Yes! : )
Thanks for sharing this!

Miss Mustard Seed said...

I've never had buttermilk pie before, but it looks so good. Thanks for sharing and thanks for visiting my blog!

Liz said...

I love buttermilk Pie!! I think I will make some...umm!


cindy said...

LOVE me some buttermilk pie!!!! My Gran made the best (present company excluded), but where I work makes a pretty good one too. Yours looks awesome as well.

yapping cat

Blogging tips